MILWAUKEE LEGISLATION WOULD BAN COAL TAR SEALANTS
January 25, 2017 Alderman Jim Bohl (414) 286-2219
*Alderman Bohl is also a MMSD Commissioner
Council legislation would ban coal tar sealants in Milwaukee
Milwaukee would join two states, the cities of Austin, San Antonio, Seattle, Minneapolis
and Washington, D.C., Madison – and a growing list of other U.S. communities– if the Common
Council approves a proposed city ban on coal tar sealants.
A proposed ordinance authored by Alderman Jim Bohl – and recommended for
approval earlier today by the Public Works Committee -- would ban the use and sale of coal tar
sealants typically used on driveways, parking lots and playgrounds during paving projects. Coal
tar materials have been shown to contain a highly toxic additive that poses serious health and
Alderman Bohl said coal tar sealants have been shown to contain heavy amounts of
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons – or PAHs – a known human carcinogen. A recent Milwaukee
Journal Sentinel article revealed a study by the U.S. Geological Survey and Milwaukee
Metropolitan Sewerage District (MMSD) which showed coal tar sealants are the primary source
of toxic chemicals found in the muck around Milwaukee area waterways.
“These PAHs can be washed over time into rivers, streams, and lakes, and they can be
tracked into homes and buildings on our shoes or via dust,” Alderman Bohl said. “We need to be
out front on this immediate health and environmental threat, and the citywide ban is the best first
step we can take.”
According to Alderman Bohl, PAHs have been shown to increase cancer rates in humans 38 times over lifetime exposure, and have been shown to cause an increased risk in skin, lung, bladder, kidney, and digestive tract cancers, along with decreased immune function, cataracts, asthma and breathing problems/lung abnormalities, skin inflammation, adverse birth outcomes for babies born to exposed mothers (lower birth rate, premature delivery and heart malformations), lower IQ rates and increased behavioral problems in children. In addition, he said PAHs are toxic to mammals, birds, fish, frogs, and plants, and are particularly harmful to rivers and creeks that received runoff from municipal storm sewers, wreaking havoc on the ecology and health of those ecosystems.
The Department of Public Works has discontinued use of the sealants on city projects, and Home Depot, Lowes, Menards, and True Value and Ace Hardware no longer carry coal tar sealer products (although the product is still available with certain contractors).
Austin banned coal tar sealants in 2006, and just four years after the ban Ladybird Lake in Austin saw a 58% reduction in PAH levels. A 2012 Minnesota Pollution Control Agency study estimated the cleanup costs of PAHs to be between $1-5 billion in contaminated storm water ways in the Twin Cities area alone.
The proposed ordinance – cosponsored by Alderman Nik Kovac and Alderman Michael J. Murphy – is expected to be heard by the full Common Council at its February 7 regular meeting at City Hall.